United Services Automobile Association v. Neary

Fifteen-year-old Kevin Michaud fired a single shot from a revolver belonging to his parents, killing one friend and seriously wounding another. The parents of the two victims sued Kevin, his parents, and their insurance company, United Services Automobile Association (USAA). The Michauds' liability policy provided a $300,000 limit for "Each Occurrence" of "Personal Liability." The superior court ruled that the policy afforded $900,000 of coverage because there had been a single occurrence and Kevin and his parents were each entitled to a separate per-occurrence policy limit. USAA appealed, arguing that the policy affords a single per-occurrence policy limit of $300,000 regardless of the number of insureds. The victims' parents also appealed, arguing that not only were there three individual coverage limits, one each for Kevin and his parents, but there were also multiple occurrences. Upon review, the Supreme Court concluded that USAA's position was most in accord with the express language of the policy, the reasonable expectations of an insured, and case law, and therefore reversed the superior court's decision. View "United Services Automobile Association v. Neary" on Justia Law