Justia Insurance Law Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Government & Administrative Law
Bombardini v. Board of Psychology
A licensed psychologist faced disciplinary action after being convicted in 2018 of insurance fraud related to a workers’ compensation claim. The Board of Psychology issued an accusation in 2019 based on the conviction and also alleged dishonesty in her 2007 license application for failing to disclose a 1984 conviction. Following a two-day evidentiary hearing in 2020, the Board found cause to discipline her solely for the insurance fraud conviction, dismissed the charge related to the 1984 conviction, and placed her on probation for five years with various conditions, holding the probation in abeyance during periods when she was not practicing in California.After moving out of state and returning, the psychologist petitioned the Board in 2023 for early termination of her probation. The Board held an evidentiary hearing in 2024, found she failed to provide clear and convincing evidence of rehabilitation—citing her lack of insight and responsibility for the insurance fraud conviction—and denied the petition. The Board noted her probation had been tolled due to her absence and non-practice. She then sought judicial review of both the 2021 probation decision and the 2024 denial of early termination in the Superior Court of Sacramento County.The Superior Court denied her petition, finding the challenge to the 2021 decision untimely and concluding the 2024 denial was supported by substantial evidence. On appeal, the California Court of Appeal, Third Appellate District, affirmed the trial court’s judgment. The Court held that the trial court properly applied the substantial evidence test to review the Board’s denial of early termination, as this was analogous to review of an agency’s decision on reinstatement rather than discipline. The Court found the Board did not abuse its discretion and rejected arguments regarding procedural unfairness and relevance of the 1984 conviction. The judgment was affirmed. View "Bombardini v. Board of Psychology" on Justia Law
Shamrock Hills, LLC v. State of Iowa
A residential contractor in Iowa received warning notices from the Iowa Insurance Division, alleging that its business activities and advertising involved unlicensed public adjusting, which is regulated by two Iowa statutes. These statutes require public adjusters to be licensed and prohibit residential contractors from representing or negotiating insurance claims on behalf of property owners for the same project on which they perform work. Violations can lead to significant penalties. After the contractor was notified of alleged violations related to its advertising and communications with consumers, it challenged the constitutionality of the statutes, claiming they are void for vagueness and infringe upon First Amendment rights, both facially and as applied.The United States District Court for the Southern District of Iowa dismissed the contractor’s suit. The court found that the State of Iowa and its Insurance Division were immune under the Eleventh Amendment. It further held that the contractor failed to state a cognizable claim under the First or Fourteenth Amendments, concluding the statutes regulated conduct, not speech, and were not unconstitutionally vague.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. The appellate court held that the statutes are not facially unconstitutional and are not void for vagueness. However, the court found that the district court erred by not adequately analyzing the contractor’s as-applied First Amendment challenge. Specifically, when the statutes were applied to restrict the contractor from telling insureds that it would assist or advise them in navigating the insurance claims process, the law regulated speech. The court reversed the dismissal of the as-applied First Amendment claim and remanded for further proceedings, while affirming the rejection of the facial and vagueness challenges. View "Shamrock Hills, LLC v. State of Iowa" on Justia Law
The Workers’ Compensation Rating and Inspection Bureau of Massachusetts v. Commissioner of Insurance
The dispute centers on two decisions by the Massachusetts Commissioner of Insurance regarding proposed statewide workers’ compensation insurance rates. The Workers’ Compensation Rating and Inspection Bureau of Massachusetts, the sole licensed rating organization for such insurance in the state, submitted rate filings for July 1, 2024, proposing a 7.6 percent decrease, and for July 1, 2025, proposing a 7.1 percent increase. The Commissioner disapproved the 2024 proposal, instead ordering a 14.6 percent decrease, and rejected the 2025 proposal, leaving the 2024 rates unchanged. Both decisions followed administrative hearings, with participation from the State Rating Bureau and the Attorney General.After the Commissioner’s 2024 decision, the Bureau sought review in the Supreme Judicial Court for Suffolk County, which was reserved and reported to the full Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. The 2025 decision was similarly reviewed and consolidated with the earlier case. The Bureau’s main challenges were to the Commissioner’s use of a five-year data period for estimating indemnity paid losses (instead of the two years used historically), the methodology for calculating underwriting profit, and a change in data sources for a particular business classification (class code 9033).The Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts held that the Commissioner had reasonable support for disapproving the Bureau’s proposed rates, particularly due to the need to account for anomalous data from the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the Court found that the Commissioner failed to provide a reasoned explanation for ordering a specific 14.6 percent rate decrease in 2024 and for the methodology change for class code 9033. The Court affirmed the finding that the then-existing rates were excessive but remanded the case for the Commissioner to provide further explanation for both the rate decrease and the class code methodology. View "The Workers' Compensation Rating and Inspection Bureau of Massachusetts v. Commissioner of Insurance" on Justia Law
Victory Insurance Co. v. State Auditor
Victory Insurance Company, a Montana insurer, served as managing general agent for Clear Spring Property and Casualty Company’s workers’ compensation policies. When Clear Spring terminated their agreement, a dispute arose, leading to federal litigation. In 2021, Clear Spring notified the Montana Commissioner of Securities and Insurance that Victory had refused to provide required data related to its agency work. The Commissioner demanded Victory turn over all relevant records in a format usable to the agency, specifically requesting comma-separated value (.csv) files unless the native format was not conducive. Victory instead provided PDF documents and links to sample data, stating it did not use .csv formatting and that Clear Spring already possessed the requested information.The Commissioner initiated administrative proceedings, alleging violations of the Montana Insurance Code, including failure to provide records in a usable form. After a contested hearing, the agency’s Hearing Examiner granted summary judgment for the Commissioner, finding Victory violated the statute by not providing the records in the specified format. The Special Deputy Insurance Commissioner affirmed this decision and imposed a $25,000 fine for each violation. Victory sought judicial review in the Montana First Judicial District Court, arguing the agency misinterpreted the law and acted arbitrarily in imposing the maximum fine. The District Court affirmed the agency’s decision and the penalties.The Supreme Court of the State of Montana reviewed the case de novo. The Court held that the statute requires managing general agents to provide access to records in a form usable to the Commissioner as specified at the time of request, and the Commissioner was not required to prove incapacity to use other formats. The Court affirmed summary judgment against Victory, finding no genuine dispute of material fact. It also ruled that the $25,000-per-violation fine was authorized by statute and was not arbitrary or capricious, affirming the District Court's decision in full. View "Victory Insurance Co. v. State Auditor" on Justia Law
Ralph L. Wadsworth Constr. Co. v. Reg’l Rail Partners
A public entity contracted with a general contractor to construct a major rail line project. The general contractor, in turn, subcontracted a significant portion of the work to a subcontractor. As the project progressed, it experienced numerous delays and disruptions, which the subcontractor claimed increased its costs. After completing its performance, the subcontractor, relying on expert analysis of its additional costs, filed a verified statement of claim under the Colorado Public Works Act, asserting it was owed additional millions for labor, materials, and other costs, including those stemming from delay and disruption.Following the filing, the general contractor substituted a surety bond for the retained project funds and the subcontractor initiated litigation in Denver District Court. After a bench trial, the trial court found in favor of the subcontractor, concluding that its verified statement of claim was not excessive and that there was a reasonable possibility the claimed amount was due. The court awarded the subcontractor damages for delay, disruption, and unpaid funds. The general contractor appealed, contending the claim was excessive and should result in forfeiture of all rights to the claimed amount. The Colorado Court of Appeals reversed in relevant part, holding that the verified statement of claim was excessive as a matter of law and that the subcontractor forfeited all rights to the amount claimed. This disposition left certain issues raised by the subcontractor on cross-appeal unaddressed.The Supreme Court of Colorado granted review and held that, under the Public Works Act, disputed or unliquidated amounts—including delay and disruption damages—may be included in a verified statement of claim if they represent the specified categories of costs and the claim is not excessive under the statute. The court also held that filing an excessive claim results only in forfeiture of statutory remedies under the Act, not all legal remedies. The Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals’ judgment and remanded for further proceedings. View "Ralph L. Wadsworth Constr. Co. v. Reg'l Rail Partners" on Justia Law
Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau v. Technology Insurance Company
Several insurance companies participate in Indiana’s Assigned Risk Plan, a statutory system designed to ensure workers’ compensation coverage for employers unable to obtain insurance in the voluntary market. One participating insurer, Technology Insurance Company, provided coverage under this system. After handling a significant workers’ compensation claim and settling for over $2 million, the company sought reimbursement from the Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau, as provided in their agreements. The Bureau denied reimbursement, alleging the company had acted fraudulently. The company followed the dispute-resolution procedures required by contract, ultimately securing a favorable ruling from an administrative law judge, who ordered full reimbursement. The company then sought additional relief—attorneys’ fees, interest, and expenses—from the agency, but received no response despite repeated requests.After payment of the principal settlement amount but no fees or interest, the company sought judicial review in the Marion Superior Court, which found the Department of Insurance’s failure to rule was arbitrary and contrary to law. The trial court ordered the Bureau to pay fees, interest, and expenses. The Bureau appealed, and the Indiana Court of Appeals reversed, holding the company’s claims for fees were not governed by the parties’ agreements and must be presented anew to the Bureau.The Indiana Supreme Court granted transfer, vacating the appellate court’s decision. The Court held that the company was required to exhaust administrative remedies, as set out in the Assigned Risk Plan and related agreements, but found the company had done so by pursuing its claims through the prescribed channels. The Court further held that the company was entitled to prejudgment interest, attorneys’ fees, and expenses under the contracts, and that these collateral claims could properly be added in the judicial review proceedings without further agency exhaustion. The judgment for the company was affirmed and the case remanded to the trial court for calculation and award of appropriate fees, interest, and expenses. View "Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau v. Technology Insurance Company" on Justia Law
MCKINNEY v. SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS
A veteran who suffered a traumatic brain injury from an improvised explosive device while deployed sought financial assistance under the Traumatic Servicemembers’ Group Life Insurance (TSGLI) program after experiencing a stroke within two years of the injury. The Army denied his claim, determining the stroke was a physical illness or disease, not a qualifying traumatic injury as defined by the relevant statute and regulations. The veteran then petitioned the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to amend its rules to include coverage for illnesses or diseases caused by explosive ordnance, arguing these conditions are analogous to those already covered under existing exceptions for injuries resulting from chemical, biological, or radiological weapons.The VA initially denied the rulemaking petition but agreed to further review as part of a program-wide assessment. After several years, extensive consultation with medical experts, and consideration of the petition and supporting materials, the VA issued a final denial. It concluded that expanding coverage to delayed illnesses or diseases linked to explosive ordnance would be inconsistent with TSGLI’s purpose, which focuses on immediate injuries, would deviate from the insurance model underlying the program, and could threaten its financial stability. The VA also found insufficient evidence of a direct causal relationship between explosive ordnance, traumatic brain injury, and downstream illnesses like stroke.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reviewed the VA’s denial under the highly deferential “arbitrary and capricious” standard of the Administrative Procedure Act. The court held that the VA provided a reasoned explanation addressing the petitioner’s arguments and the record, and did not act arbitrarily or capriciously. The petition for review was therefore denied. View "MCKINNEY v. SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS " on Justia Law
Myres v. Bd. of Admin. for CalPERS
A longtime deputy sheriff was convicted by a federal jury of mail and wire fraud after she submitted an insurance claim for items stolen during a burglary at her home, some of which she falsely claimed as her own but actually belonged to her employer, the sheriff’s office. She also used her employer’s fax machine and cover sheet in communicating with the insurance company and misrepresented her supervisor’s identity. The criminal conduct arose after a romantic relationship with a former inmate ended badly, leading to the burglary, but the fraud conviction was based on her false insurance claim, not on the relationship or the burglary itself.Following her conviction, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) determined that her crimes constituted conduct “arising out of or in the performance of her official duties” under Government Code section 7522.72, part of the Public Employees Pension Reform Act, and partially forfeited her pension. The administrative law judge and the San Francisco Superior Court both upheld CalPERS’s decision, reasoning that her actions were sufficiently connected to her employment, particularly in her misuse of employer property and resources and in the context of her relationship with the former inmate.The Court of Appeal of the State of California, First Appellate District, Division One, reversed the trial court’s judgment. The appellate court held that the statute requires a specific causal nexus between the criminal conduct and the employee’s official duties, not merely any job-related connection. The court found that the deputy’s fraudulent insurance claim, although it referenced employer property and resources, did not arise out of or in the performance of her official duties as required by the statute. Accordingly, the pension forfeiture determination was set aside. View "Myres v. Bd. of Admin. for CalPERS" on Justia Law
California FAIR Plan Assn. v. Lara
A dispute arose between the California FAIR Plan Association (CFPA), a statutorily created insurer of last resort, and the state’s Insurance Commissioner. The Commissioner issued an order in 2021 directing CFPA to submit a plan to offer and sell a comprehensive “Homeowners’ Policy” that included, among other coverages, premises liability and incidental workers’ compensation. CFPA challenged this order, contending that the Basic Property Insurance Law only required it to provide first-party property insurance—coverage for direct loss to property—not liability coverage or similar third-party protections.The Superior Court of Los Angeles County denied CFPA’s petition for a writ of mandate. The court found ambiguity in the statutory definition of “basic property insurance,” specifically in the phrase allowing for “other insurance coverages as may be added.” Deeming the term ambiguous, the court deferred to the Department of Insurance’s interpretation that allowed the Commissioner to require CFPA to offer additional coverages, including liability insurance, so long as such coverages had a connection to the insured property. The court relied in part on the longstanding approval of liability coverage in certain businessowner policies since the early 1990s.The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Three, reviewed the lower court’s decision de novo. It concluded that, while the statutory language was ambiguous, extrinsic evidence such as legislative history and statutory context demonstrated that the Legislature intended for CFPA to be limited to providing first-party property insurance. The court found no sufficient basis to defer to the Department of Insurance’s later-adopted interpretation that expanded coverage to liability. The Court of Appeal reversed the judgment and directed the trial court to grant CFPA’s petition for writ of mandate, holding that the Commissioner lacked authority under the Basic Property Insurance Law to require CFPA to offer liability coverage. View "California FAIR Plan Assn. v. Lara" on Justia Law
Government Employees Ins. Co. v Mayzenberg
Several insurance companies initiated a federal lawsuit against a licensed acupuncturist, three professional service corporations under his control, and two unlicensed individuals. The insurers sought a declaration that one of the corporations was not entitled to no-fault insurance reimbursement for services rendered, alleging the corporation engaged in a scheme to pay unlicensed individuals for patient referrals. The payments allegedly violated New York’s professional conduct rules but did not involve the transfer of control over the corporation to unlicensed persons.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York found that the acupuncturist and his corporations had engaged in an unlawful fee-splitting and kickback scheme, violating New York law. The court ruled that this professional misconduct rendered the corporation ineligible for no-fault reimbursement under the relevant Department of Financial Services (DFS) regulation and granted summary judgment for the insurers. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit agreed that the referral fees were paid but found it unclear whether this type of professional misconduct made the provider ineligible for reimbursement under the regulation. It certified to the New York Court of Appeals the question of whether such misconduct, absent ceding control to unlicensed persons, permits denial of no-fault benefits.The New York Court of Appeals held that the DFS regulation does not authorize insurers to deny no-fault reimbursement based solely on a provider’s alleged professional misconduct, such as paying for patient referrals, unless that misconduct amounts to a failure to meet a foundational licensing requirement—specifically, surrendering control of the professional practice to unlicensed individuals. The court deferred to DFS’s longstanding interpretation that only licensing violations resulting in loss of eligibility to practice, as determined by regulators, justify denial of reimbursement. The court answered the certified question in the negative. View "Government Employees Ins. Co. v Mayzenberg" on Justia Law